Yesterday’s hero is tomorrow’s bum. It is a sad fact of life, regardless of industry, sport, volunteer organization or community group. Rarely does one person succeed or fail alone, however it is far easier to lay the blame on one individual than to take a hard look at an entire organization. Colin Kaepernick was able to reap the glory and the rewards as an NFL quarterback when he was the face of the 49ers in their Super Bowl and NFC Champion teams. Less than two years removed from such heights, he is paying the price as the franchise struggles, finding himself benched. How quickly things change.
Colin Kaepernick’s fall from grace parallels the 49ers slide from the top echelon of the NFL. As with most things in life, there is plenty of blame to go around, and the truth tends to lie somewhere in the middle. It is highly doubtful that Kaepernick suddenly forgot how to play the game, that his talent suddenly evaporated. Conversely, the organization did not suddenly implode. The other players did not suddenly forget how to block, run, catch and defend. However, this story is a great reminder that there is a lot more to career decisions than just money.
There tends to be 5 criteria or “buckets” that enter into the decision-making process regarding jobs and/or job changes:
- What is the job? What is it you will be doing?
- Who will you be working for and with?
- The culture/environment/dynamic of the organization, industry and team
- Are you set-up for success? Do you have the resources, support, etc.
- What is the compensation and how are you paid?
There is actually a rank order to that list, and while the middle three can change in relative importance, the first and last items are and should remain where they are, first and last. What you will be doing trumps all else, and compensation only matters if the previous four items are in alignment. While most folks agree with the 5 items, many disagree with the relative order. Most folks place compensation above all else, and that is where most problems start.
Looking at the above list relative to Colin Kaepernick, it is easy to see how the first item did not change – he was a quarterback and his job did not change. Did he fail to develop his professional skills? Did the competition improve their game? In both cases, probably yes, but in the end, he did not suddenly forget how to be a quarterback.
Who he is working for and with changed dramatically. Jim Harbaugh left as head coach, and with him went the entire coaching staff. The individual players who make up the team also went through massive change. While the job did not change, his leadership, his coaches, his coordinators, and his co-workers all changed. That is an enormous issue.
With leadership change comes cultural and organizational change. Sometimes it is good, sometimes it is bad, but it does change. By all accounts, the 49ers were a well run, professional, no-nonsense organization before. Now, well they seem to be struggling to find an identity; they are not the organization they were when they were winning.
Change the members of the team, change the leadership, and change the culture, and the result is you change the very things that enable one to succeed. Talent, hard work, dedication, and passion can only get one so far. To borrow a phrase, to one degree or another, it actually does “take a village”. For Kaepernick, the talent around him on the field, on the sidelines, in-game planning and preparation, the culture of the locker room, in the front office, everything changed. Apparently not for the better. Regardless, it is not a scenario where one is set-up for success.
In less than 2 seasons, he and the team have become a glaring illustration of how there is much more to the debate than just compensation. Kaepernick, based on his earlier success, was able to secure a lucrative contract. Good for him. It is not healthy to begrudge someone getting paid. However, his level of compensation impacted what the organization had available to pay others. The team around him slipped in talent level. There was a conflict in leadership, and his coaching staff changed. The culture around him and the general work environment changed, and the support and tools to succeed went away.
When debating that next promotion, that great new job with the great pay, the new bonus potential, the corner office, the sweet benefits, the next contract, stop and think about Colin Kaepernick. Pro Bowler, Super Bowl playing, NFC Championship winning quarterback, huge new contract, to the bench in less than 2 years. Sure, he gets some of the blame, but just as his success was not a one man show, neither is his failure. Take a hard look at that offer, make sure what the job is, who you will be working for and with, do you have the resources, is the corporate culture good, and then worry about the money.